Talk:Guthix godsword (Beaky4444)

A Guthix godsword is a bad idea in general. Guthix didn't fight in the god wars, and merely awoke to stop said wars. He certainly didn't employ powerful soldiers, either. So, while it shouldn't be deleted, this page and its associated "God Wars Dungeon Guthix Section" pages aren't at all lore-friendly.

Karshí 17:07, June 18, 2010 (UTC)

Edit: By this I mean all of the Guthix god wars dungeon Guthix section pages created- several users have made them.

E.G. Janai Protex.

Karshí 17:08, June 18, 2010 (UTC)

My opinion of the Guthix GWD section
It's true, Guthix was sleeping during the God Wars. But there still could be some Guthix soldiers, which have been hidden behind the frozen door (that one with the Saradomin, Zamorak, Armadyl and Bandos symbols).

And if you haven't already noticed, there are many articles which won't be able to make it into the game. 13:06, June 19, 2010 (UTC)

This would be wrong. Because Guthix wouldn't fight within the God Wars. You know, after the war ended, his men rebuilt the Gielinor. Why would he fight if he was gonna rebuild Gielinor again. in the other hand, hes the god of balance and nature. which means he shouldn't fight with others he should keep the world balanced. And why would his warriors (if he has) fight without his permission.